Access to Information
In this line of work I explore how government transparency policies (Access to Information laws and Open Data policies) impact journalists’ access to information and data journalism practices in a comparative context.
-
Testing a Typology of Data Journalism: Professional and Epistemological Orientations Across and Between Global Regions
Gerry Lanosga, Lindita Camaj, and Jason Martin, Journalism Practice (2024)
This article provides analysis of the growing data journalism subfield using data gathered from a cross-national survey of journalists in 68 countries. The study makes two contributions to the literature, first offering a test of a typological framework for categorizing data journalists based on their work routines and conditions, and second exploring similarities and differences between journalists working in Global South settings versus those in the Global North. The analysis provides empirical support for conceptual claims of contrasting paradigms revolving around traditional journalistic practices versus more computational approaches to using data in news production. At the same time, we find that rather than aligning neatly with one or the other professional or epistemological paradigm, data journalists tend to employ a wide range of practices, with variations in degree of adoption of individual approaches contingent on specific work contexts. Journalists in countries of the Global South, for instance, are likelier than their Global North counterparts to adopt strategies such as using non-expert sources of information to produce stories based on data. Overall, the data suggest a maturing global data journalism field characterized by broad diffusion of standardized practices that feature some regional variation likely tied to differing data access regimes. ACCESS HERE.
-
The audience turn in Data Journalism: How do data journalists conceptualize and perform audience engagement in a Global context?
Lindita Camaj, Jason Martin, and Gerry Lanosga, Book chapter in Jingrong Tong (ed.), Data journalism and the COVID disruption (pp.160-172). New York, NY: Routledge. 2024
-
A global perspective on data journalism materiality: Knowledge production across public transparency infrastructure environments
Lindita Camaj, Gerry Lanosga, and Jason Martin, Digital Journalism (2023)
It is widely accepted that data materiality serves as the breeding ground of data journalism’s performativity, in some cases functioning as the sole ingredient for news construction. Material identity is closely tied to the historical process that originated it, yet few studies have explored how unequal public policies on government transparency affect news production in data journalism. We bring in a fresh perspective on materiality that taps into research on public transparency to offer a framework for understanding how external social actors influence data knowledge construction. This study analyzed data journalism project entries in the Global Editors Network (GEN) and Sigma Awards from 61 countries to explore data journalism process and products across transparency environments. Results suggest that journalists operating in open data infrastructure are more likely to exhibit a dependency on preprocessed public data and their output exhibits topical diversity, while journalists operating in closed data infrastructures are more likely to use Right to Information legislation and alternative data sources. This study informs the debate on the empiricism of data journalism in knowledge construction, emphasizing how data access (or lack of access) affects not only journalistic epistemology but also power relationships and journalistic roles. ACCESS HERE.
-
Scrape, request, collect, repeat: How data journalists around the World transcend obstacles to public data?
Jason Martin, Lindita Camaj, & Gerry Lanosga, Journalism Practice (2022)
In this paper, we explore innovative ways to overcome public data access barriers based on in-depth interviews with 34 data journalists working around the globe. We rely on a novel theoretical framework that combines global adoption of Freedom of Information and Open Government Data policies in a 2x2 typology to map out practical solutions across data transparency environments. ACCESS HERE.
-
The impact of public transparency infrastructure on data journalism: A comparative analysis of data access between information-rich and information-poor countries
Lindita Camaj, Jason Martin & Gerry Lanosga
Digital Journalism (2022)Based on a survey with data journalists from 71 countries, this study compares how FOIa laws and Open Government data policies influences data journalism practices around the world. The results suggest that technical and economic inequalities that affect the implementation of the open data infrastructures can produce unequal data access and widen the gap in data journalism practices between information-rich and information-poor countries. ACCESS HERE
-
Freedom of Information
Laura Stein & Lindita Camaj
Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Communication. Oxford University Press (2018)This article provides an overview of the normative assumptions behind FOIa legislation, the evolution of FOIa laws and rights, FOIa users and usage, and barriers and challenges to accessing information through FOIa laws. ACCESS HERE.
-
Blurring the boundaries between journalism and activism: A transparency agenda-building case study from Bulgaria.
Lindita Camaj
Journalism (2016)This article explores the relationship between journalists and civil society actors in promoting the Freedom of Information right in Bulgaria. It emphasizes the importance of civil society as influential actors in the media agenda-building process and presents a new approach to conceptualizing the journalist/non-governmental organization relationship from a cooperative rather than power-distance perspective. ACCESS HERE.
-
Governments’ uses and misuses of Freedom of Information laws in emerging European democracies: FOI laws’ impact on news agenda-building in Albania, Kosovo, and Montenegro.
Lindita Camaj
Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly (2016)This study tests the normative assumptions on the empowerment effects of freedom of information (FOI) legislation on the press–government relationship in the context of new democracies. ACCESS HERE.
-
From ‘window dressing’ to ‘door openers’? Freedom of Information legislation, public demand, and state compliance in Southeast Europe.
Lindita Camaj
Government Information Quarterly (2016)This comparative study examines the outcomes of FOI laws in the context of new democracies of South East Europe. It adopts a mix methodological approach to (1) examine citizen demand for access to information and government compliance with FOI laws and (2) explore structural and political conditions that affect demand and compliance. ACCESS HERE.
-
Gate-keeping the gatekeepers: International community and Freedom of Information in Kosovo.
Lindita Camaj
Global Media Journal (2010)The aim of this study is to analyze the impact of the international factors on the implementation of the Freedom of Information (FOI) legislation in Kosovo and to explore how this legislation affects media access to information in this transitional society. ACCESS HERE.